Disable Sound from Notificationchannel

Disable sound from NotificationChannel

(Update 2019-05: It gets worse with Android Q, there I'm even getting a sound when using NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_LOW, at least in the Emulator...)

The solution is to use NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_LOW and create a new channel for it. Once a channel is created, you can't change the importance (well, you can, but the new importance is ignored). The channel information appears to get stored permanently by the system and any channel created is only deleted when you uninstall the app. [Update: According to Ferran Negre's comment, you can delete the channel via nm.deleteNotificationChannel(nChannel.getId()); and recreate it with nm.createNotificationChannel(nChannel); but apparently there's a limitation that you can't create a channel with the same id of a deleted channel and expect to be able to apply different settings to the undeleted channel, see acoder's answer]

While previous Android versions played no sound back by default, this changed with Android O, but only when you target the API 26, that is, use Notification Channels. This is an inconsistency, well, actually, it's a bug:

The reason for this is that when you create a channel with NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT (not soundworthy by default) Android will actually "somewhat" register it as NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_HIGH (plays sound by default).

You can check this by going into the options of the notifications (long press on the notification entry), where you will get to read that it is of type NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_HIGH and then disable the notification and then re-enable it. In this process it gets "downgraded" from the NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_HIGH to the non-sounding, actually registered NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT.

The bug has been submitted to the Android issue tracker, so you may want to star it (flagged by Google as "Won't Fix (Infeasible)", because... spoiled).

BTW, the new docs at https://developer.android.com/training/notify-user/channels
claim that the default behavior used to be that way, that default played a sound prior to Android 8.0, which is definitely not true. This is their list

User-visible importance level           Importance               Priority   
                                        (Android 8.0 and higher) (Android 7.1 and lower)
Urgent  Makes a sound and appears as    IMPORTANCE_HIGH          PRIORITY_HIGH
        a heads-up notification                                  or PRIORITY_MAX
High    Makes a sound                   IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT       PRIORITY_DEFAULT
Medium  No sound                        IMPORTANCE_LOW           PRIORITY_LOW
Low     No sound and does not appear    IMPORTANCE_MIN           PRIORITY_MIN
        in the status bar

You can even see the mismatch between visibility importance high and notification importance high... I don't know why they are doing this. They definitely have a bug in their code.

Everything below the next line is obsolete, yet that bug mentioned there is still valid. My error there was to think that NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_MIN is the next lower one from NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT, but NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_LOW is.

When you then go into the notification settings of the app via long-press-notification and all-channels button and toggle the switch for that channel off and on again, then it actually sets itself to NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT and no sound will get played. I also noticed that after a crash it did get reset to NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_HIGH

So basically the workaround is to use NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_MIN. But you have to create a new channel so that this NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_MIN is in effect, because it appears that you can't change the importance of an already existing channel once you have created it.

Update: Turns out the workaround with NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_MIN has a drawback.

When you use that importance level then your notification no longer displays fully inside the notification drawer, but inserts itself in a new Notification Channel Group which is collapsed by default (and will collapse itself again each time the drawer is pulled down). What a bummer!

Update 2: Digging a bit deeper it turns out that it is as if it correctly registered it as NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_DEFAULT, but somehow it magically got upgraded to NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_HIGH, like it would when the user explicitly changes the setting from default to high. That one also gets reset to default after turning the notification off and then on again.

How to disable notification sound with keeping heads up notification?

I solved this problem by https://stackoverflow.com/a/54785422/14019506

Thanks for DeePanShu.

how to stop Foreground service notification 'noise' programmatically when invoking notification UI display

As notification channels are a must for Oreo+ APIs, then this is most probably related to the channel.

I think you can stop this sound by using NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_LOW while creating the Foreground service notification channel.

NotificationChannel serviceChannel = new NotificationChannel(
                CHANNEL_ID,
                CHANNEL_NAME,
                NotificationManager.IMPORTANCE_LOW // <<<<<
        );

NotificationManager manager = getSystemService(NotificationManager.class);
manager.createNotificationChannel(serviceChannel);

How to disable sound/vibration for notification updates on a channel (API 26+)?

On all API levels, you can disable sound and vibration for notification updates by use setOnlyAlertOnce():

Set this flag if you would only like the sound, vibrate and ticker to be played if the notification is not already showing.

builder.setOnlyAlertOnce(true)

This will ensure that updates to an existing notification won't sound/vibrate.

Disable Sound from Notificationchannel