When to use Struct instead of Hash in Ruby?
Structs differ from using hashmaps in the following ways (in addition to how the code looks):
- A struct has a fixed set of attributes, while you add new keys to a hash.
- Calling an attribute that does not exist on an instance of a struct will cause a NoMethodError, while getting the value for a non-existing key from a hash will just return nil.
- Two instances of different structs will never be equal even if the structs have the same attributes and the instances have the same values (i.e.
Struct.new(:x).new(42) == Struct.new(:x).new(42)
is false, whereasFoo = Struct.new(:x); Foo.new(42)==Foo.new(42)
is true). - The
to_a
method for structs returns an array of values, whileto_a
on a hash gets you an array of key-value-pairs (where "pair" means "two-element array") - If
Foo = Struct.new(:x, :y, :z)
you can doFoo.new(1,2,3)
to create an instance ofFoo
without having to spell out the attribute names.
So to answer the question: When you want to model objects with a known set of attributes, use structs. When you want to model arbitrary use hashmaps (e.g. counting how often each word occurs in a string or mapping nicknames to full names etc. are definitely not jobs for a struct, while modeling a person with a name, an age and an address would be a perfect fit for Person = Struct.new(name, age, address)
).
As a sidenote: C structs have little to nothing to do with ruby structs, so don't let yourself get confused by that.
When is it better to use a Struct rather than a Hash in Ruby?
Personally I use a struct in cases when I want to make a piece of data act like a collection of data instead of loosely coupled under a Hash
.
For instance I've made a script that downloads videos from Youtube and in there I've a struct to represent a Video and to test whether all data is in place:
Video = Struct.new(:title, :video_id, :id) do
def to_s
"http://youtube.com/get_video.php?t=#{id}&video_id=#{video_id}&fmt=18"
end
def empty?
@title.nil? and @video_id.nil? and @id.nil?
end
end
Later on in my code I've a loop that goes through all rows in the videos source HTML-page until empty?
doesn't return true.
Another example I've seen is James Edward Gray IIs configuration class which uses OpenStruct
to easily add configuration variables loaded from an external file:
#!/usr/bin/env ruby -wKU
require "ostruct"
module Config
module_function
def load_config_file(path)
eval <<-END_CONFIG
config = OpenStruct.new
#{File.read(path)}
config
END_CONFIG
end
end
# configuration_file.rb
config.db = File.join(ENV['HOME'], '.cool-program.db')
config.user = ENV['USER']
# Usage:
Config = Config.load_config('configuration_file.rb')
Config.db # => /home/ba/.cool-program.db
Config.user # => ba
Config.non_existant # => Nil
The difference between Struct
and OpenStruct
is that Struct
only responds to the attributes that you've set, OpenStruct
responds to any attribute set - but those with no value set will return Nil
When should I use an OpenStruct instead of a Hash?
I think this mostly comes down to a performance decision. From the Ruby Documentation:
An OpenStruct utilizes Ruby’s method lookup structure to and find and define the necessary methods for properties. This is accomplished through the method method_missing and define_method.
This should be a consideration if there is a concern about the performance of the objects that are created, as there is much more overhead in the setting of these properties compared to using a Hash or a Struct.
Additionally, something like a Hash
has additional functionality with all of the methods it provides (has_key?
, include?
, etc.). The OpenStruct
is a very simple object from that standpoint, but if you don't have any concerns from a performance standpoint and just want an easy object to work with, OpenStruct
is a good choice.
When should I use Struct vs. OpenStruct?
With an OpenStruct
, you can arbitrarily create attributes. A Struct
, on the other hand, must have its attributes defined when you create it. The choice of one over the other should be based primarily on whether you need to be able to add attributes later.
The way to think about them is as the middle ground of the spectrum between Hashes on one side and classes on the other. They imply a more concrete relationship amongst the data than does a Hash
, but they don't have the instance methods as would a class. A bunch of options for a function, for example, make sense in a hash; they're only loosely related. A name, email, and phone number needed by a function could be packaged together in a Struct
or OpenStruct
. If that name, email, and phone number needed methods to provide the name in both "First Last" and "Last, First" formats, then you should create a class to handle it.
Ruby Class vs Struct
From the Struct docs:
A Struct is a convenient way to bundle a number of attributes together, using accessor methods, without having to write an explicit class.
The Struct class generates new subclasses that hold a set of members and their values. For each member a reader and writer method is created similar to Module#attr_accessor.
So, if I want a Person
class that I can access a name attribute (read and write), I either do it by declaring a class:
class Person
attr_accessor :name
def initalize(name)
@name = name
end
end
or using Struct:
Person = Struct.new(:name)
In both cases I can run the following code:
person = Person.new
person.name = "Name"
#or Person.new("Name")
puts person.name
When use it?
As the description states we use Structs when we need a group of accessible attributes without having to write an explicit class.
For example I want a point variable to hold X and Y values:
point = Struct.new(:x, :y).new(20,30)
point.x #=> 20
Some more examples:
- http://blog.steveklabnik.com/posts/2012-09-01-random-ruby-tricks--struct-new
- "When to use Struct instead of Hash in Ruby?" also has some very good points (comparing to the use of hash).
Whats are some important differences between an OpenStruct and a Hash?
OpenStructs are sloooooooooow and memory intensive , and don't scale well for large data sets.
Creating 1 million OpenStructs is ~100x slower than creating 1 million Hashes.
This has been discussed in detail here:
When should I use Struct vs. OpenStruct?
returning struct data as a hash in ruby
Ruby <= 1.9.3 has OpenStruct#marshall_dump and Struct#each_pair:
Person = Struct.new(:name, :age)
person = Person.new("Jamie", 23)
person_hash = Hash[person.each_pair.to_a]
#=> {:age=>23, :name=>"Jamie"}
Ruby 2.0 provides Struct#to_h and OpenStruct#to_h:
Person = Struct.new(:name, :age)
person = Person.new("Jamie", 23)
person_hash = person.to_h
#=> {:age=>23, :name=>"Jamie"}
Ruby: Struct vs Initialize
The class (non-struct) has a simpler ancestry tree:
>> Fruit.ancestors
=> [Fruit, Object, Kernel, BasicObject]
As compared to the struct version:
>> Fruit.ancestors
=> [Fruit, #<Class:0x1101c9038>, Struct, Enumerable, Object, Kernel, BasicObject]
So, the Struct class could be mistaken for an array (rare, but absolutely could happen)
fruit = Fruit.new("yo")
# .. later
fruit.each do |k|
puts k
end
# outputs: yo
So... I use Structs as throw-away data objects. I use "real" classes in my domain and application.
When should I use a hash vs a class
From an OO point of view (and you're programming in Java...), you should use classes for that.
I don't think it adds any complexity at all. That's what classes are made for. If those classes don't have any methods but getters and setters, well, that's the place for so called TO's (Transfer Objects). And even while this should not be considered as an design argument, of course it's more debug-friendly than hashes.
Related Topics
How to Open Files Relative to Home Directory
Which Ruby Gems Support the Facebook API
What Is the Easiest Way I Can Create a 'Beep' Sound from a Ruby Program
Ruby: What Does the Asterisk in "P *1..10" Mean
Convert JSON String to JSON Array in Rails
What Are the Reserved Words Begin or End Used for in Ruby
Rails - Testing JSON API with Functional Tests
Ruby Merging Two Arrays into One
Gem Dependencies Versions Meaning
"Ago" Date/Time Functions in Ruby/Rails
Namespaced Models in Rails: What's the State of the Union
How to Check What Is Queued in Activejob Using Rspec
Comparing Times Only, Without Dates
Checking If a Method Is Defined on the Class
Switching Between Web and Touch Interfaces on Facebook Login Using Omniauth and Rails 3
Cucumber, Capybara and Selenium - Submitting a Form Without a Button